All Out Pizza And More

4.4 ( 170 reviews )
Checking... 02:00 AM - 07:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
19009 NY-12E, Dexter, NY 13634, United States
+1 315-777-8534

Located in Dexter, NY, All Out Pizza And More has earned rave reviews for its dedication to quality and customer satisfaction. Diners highlight the freshly baked rolls, as exemplified by a delicious fish sandwich that leaves patrons considering takeout options daily. The garlic parmesan buffalo wings have garnered praise from locals, even drawing in those with discerning palates from Buffalo.

Frank H., a recent convert to New York, travels 20 minutes just to enjoy the pizza, citing it as the best in the area. His heartfelt commentary reflects the welcoming atmosphere and accuracy of service, essential traits for any successful eatery. Meanwhile, Amy Jo Ayen’s enthusiastic endorsement reveals that the value and generous portion sizes truly stand out, making meals feel special.

With a recent shoutout for accommodating last-minute requests—like a birthday sheet pizza—this restaurant continually goes above and beyond for its community. All Out Pizza And More isn't just about feeding customers; it's about creating memorable experiences. If you haven’t tried it yet, make your way there—from pizza to wings, their menu promises a flavor-packed adventure you won't regret!

Amenities and More

  • From the business
    • Identifies as women-owned
  • Service options
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Great dessert
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Coffee
    • Comfort food
    • Late-night food
    • Quick bite
    • Small plates
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Catering
    • Counter service
    • Dessert
    • Seating
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Gender-neutral toilets
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
    • Groups
    • LGBTQ+ friendly
    • Tourists
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs
    • Kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot

Reviews For All Out Pizza And More

Donald Eckert
Jun 27,2025
This fish sandwich with fries was 8.99. I'm pretty sure the roll was baked in house. Everything was cooked perfectly: great price, great food. There isn't a lot of seating, but I'd do take out every day of the week if I lived closer.
MrKingslandm
Jun 26,2025
These are the garlic parm buffalo hot wings, I'm a buffalo native, these are ridiculously good!!
Frank H
Jun 21,2025
I drive about 20 minutes just to get pizza here because it is so good. I am new to New York and not used to there being nowhere to eat, especially in the winter. Why do people not want to deliver or make money in the winter? The pizza place where I live is terrible and this place is hands down the best so no matter how far, we shall travel. The staff is always welcoming and gets our order right. Thank you for being better than anyone else around you... it is worth the drive...
Amy Jo Ayen
Jun 3,2025
Just wow!! If you haven’t tried this food establishment, you better run there not walk!! This is the best tasting food we’ve had in a very long time, and also the value and portion size u get for your money is beyond outstanding...My husband and I ordered pizza, wings and antipasto salad, u can tell these folks know their food, value their customers and LOVE what they do... It’s shows in your product, we will definitely order again....WELL DONE!!...
Shaunna Cleveland
May 21,2025
We just wanted to thank you so much for making a last minute sheet pizza for our little guys Birthday ! As always it was delicious !
Isabelle Granger
Mar 13,2025
First time ordering from here. Ordered pizza, wings and antipasto. Everything was amazing, best I've had in a very long time! This will be our new go to place.
april brown
Mar 13,2025
So good. Worth the wait. Everything was so flavorful. The meat pizza was to die for. My son is a pizza connoisseur. He could not even wait to get home to dive into the pepperoni and bacon pizza. Words cannot describe the deliciousness of the garlic cheesy bread which is essentially another pizza. DO NOT order through the Slice app. It will say your order is ready when there is still at least 30 mins to go. Call directly to order to get the actual wait time.
heather merry
Mar 12,2025
We ate inside over the weekend, I got the haddock dinner and my husband got chicken tenders and hot wings. Everything was terrific! Service was great and the owner was very friendly and helpful. Then we ordered pizza tonight and brought it home. Amazing! The sauce tasted homemade. We will 100% be going there more often!!

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

PIE LIFE Pizzeria
(257 review)
PIE LIFE Pizzeria
  • 430 Roosevelt Rd, Glen Ellyn, IL 60137, United States
Pizza restaurant
+1 630-547-2309
Hung Tao
(109 review)
Hung Tao
  • 1127 North Ave Suite 23, Burlington, VT 05408, United States
chinese restaurant
+1 802-540-2598
Thai Lanna - Chasewater
(232 review)
Thai Lanna - Chasewater
  • 79 Hednesford Rd, Brownhills, Walsall WS8 7LT, United Kingdom
Thai restaurant
+44 1543 371193
Ola Mulata at Vidanta Nuevo Vallarta
(171 review)
Ola Mulata at Vidanta Nuevo Vallarta
  • Blvrd Riviera Nayarit 254, 63735 Nuevo Vallarta, Nay., Mexico
Restaurant
+52 322 224 6000
EL FOLKLORE DE MEXICO
(212 review)
EL FOLKLORE DE MEXICO
  • 1486 E Lebanon Rd, Dover, DE 19901, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 302-538-7129
Pastafina's of Cleburne
(1249 review)
Pastafina's of Cleburne
  • 1670 W Henderson St, Cleburne, TX 76033, United States
Italian restaurant
+1 817-558-2220
River Street Restaurant
(138 review)
River Street Restaurant
  • 109 River St, Milford, CT 06460, United States
Italian restaurant
+1 203-882-0071
Bourbon Chicken
(120 review)
Bourbon Chicken
  • 1000 River Dr N, Great Falls, MT 59401, United States
Restaurant
+1 406-315-2152
illy Coffee At Earth's End Princeton
(189 review)
illy Coffee At Earth's End Princeton
  • 45 Spring St, Princeton, NJ 08542, United States
Coffee shop
+1 609-356-0407
Le Parc-Bonjour, Café Bistro
(224 review)
Le Parc-Bonjour, Café Bistro
  • 997 N Greenway Dr, Coral Gables, FL 33134, United States
Restaurant
+1 305-722-8785